The Legend of Zorro (2005)
The Legend of Zorro is a 2005 American Western swashbuckler film directed by Martin Campbell, produced by Walter F. Parkes, Laurie MacDonald and Lloyd Phillips, with music by James Horner, and written by Roberto Orci and Alex Kurtzman. It is the sequel to 1998’s The Mask of Zorro; Antonio Banderas and Catherine Zeta-Jones reprise their roles as the titular hero and his spouse, Elena, and Rufus Sewell stars as the villain, Count Armand. The film takes place in San Mateo County, California and was shot in San Luis Potosí, Mexico, with second-unit photography in Wellington, New Zealand. The film was theatrically released on October 28, 2005, by Columbia Pictures (instead of TriStar due to Columbia holding the sequel rights to TriStar’s pre-1999 film library), and earned $142.4 million on a $65 million budget.
Plot.
In 1850, nine years after the events of the first film, California is voting on whether to join the United States of America as a state. Alejandro Murrieta, now known as Don Alejandro De La Vega, foils a plot to steal the ballots, but during the fight with a gunman named Jacob McGivens, he briefly loses his mask. A pair of Pinkerton agents see his face and recognize him. The following day, the agents confront Alejandro’s wife, Elena, and blackmail her into divorcing him. Three months later, the separation from Elena and his son Joaquin, and the feeling that the people no longer need Zorro, are taking their toll on Alejandro. His childhood guardian, Father Felipe, convinces him to attend a party at French Count Armand’s new vineyard. There, Alejandro discovers that Elena is dating the count, an admirer from her time spent in Europe. After leaving the party, Alejandro witnesses a huge explosion close to Armand’s mansion and becomes suspicious of him.
McGivens leads an attack on the family of Guillermo Cortez, Alejandro’s friend, to seize their land deed. Donning his mask again, Zorro succeeds in rescuing Guillermo’s wife and son, but fails to save Guillermo and the deed. Zorro follows McGivens to Armand’s mansion and discovers that Armand plans to build a railroad on Cortez’s land. He also encounters Elena and, learning of an upcoming shipment, he tracks McGivens to a cove where the cargo is delivered. Unbeknownst to him, Joaquin also hitched a ride on McGiven’s cart, having snuck out of a class field trip. Zorro saves his son from the bandits and, examining the shipment, he sees a piece of the cargo – a bar of soap – and the phrase Orbis Unum meaning One World in Latin on a crate lid. Upon researching the phrase, Felipe and Alejandro learn that Armand is the head of a secret society, the Knights of Aragon, which has been secretly ruling Europe. The United States is deemed a threat to the Knights, so they plan to throw the country into chaos before it can gain too much power.
RELATED:
Shadowless Sword (2005) Biography, Plot, Scene
Historical references.
The Legend of Zorro continues its predecessor’s inclusion of Spanish historical elements of California history into the fiction, though many liberties have been taken. Alejandro, the Mexican-born Californian who became Zorro at the end of The Mask of Zorro, is a fictional brother to Joaquin Murrieta, for whom the character’s son Joaquin is named. Military governor Bennet Riley, the last of California’s heads of state prior to statehood, is portrayed, but the Maryland-born American is played by the Mexican actor Pedro Armendáriz Jr. who speaks English with a Hispanic accent. Leo Burmester plays R. S. Beauregard, a Confederate colonel whose character is not to be confused with the historical P. G. T. Beauregard. Pedro Mira plays a pre-Presidential Abraham Lincoln as an observer to California’s statehood, though the real Lincoln never traveled to the region. The film also features a fictional monument called Bear Point, commemorating the site where the original Bear Flag of the California Republic flew briefly in 1846. Although the actual flag flew in Sonoma County, the film suggests that Bear Point is located in San Mateo County.
The Legend of Zorro, which takes place in 1850, includes a significant number of deviations from national history as well, particularly in depicting an organized Confederate States of America and a presumed completed First Transcontinental Railroad, each more than a decade before their times. Additional deviations include a quote from the Gettysburg Address, which would not be written until 1863. A map discovered by Zorro delineates two states (Arizona and New Mexico) that did not achieve statehood until 1912; several other states depicted on the map entered into the Union long after California. The film also features characters who identify themselves as agents of the Pinkerton Detective Agency, which had been established in the year 1850 but was known at the time as the North-Western Police Agency.
Reception, Home media.
The Legend of Zorro currently holds a rating of 47 out of 100 on Metacritic, and a 26% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, with its consensus stating, “Zorro can survive a lot of things, but it looks like he can’t survive marriage”. Roger Ebert of the Chicago Sun-Times gave the film a below-average review, awarding it one and a half out of four stars, commenting that “of all of the possible ideas about how to handle the Elena character, this movie has assembled the worst ones.” James Berardinelli of ReelViews gave The Legend of Zorro two out of four stars, saying that “the action is routine”, “the chemistry between the two leads, which was one of the highlights of The Mask of Zorro, has evaporated during the intervening years”, and that the movie “fails to recapture the pleasure offered by The Mask of Zorro.” The film was released on DVD and VHS on January 31, 2006. Stephanie Zacharek of Salon.com praised the film, calling it “entertaining, bold, and self-effacing at once”, noting the civic and parental questions it raises. Slate Magazine critic David Edelstein also praised the film, in particular the action scenes, villains, and chemistry between Banderas and Zeta-Jones. Mick LaSalle of the San Francisco Chronicle said the film was “watchable – not remotely enjoyable, but watchable.”
“The Legend of Zorro still feels like a half-hearted shrug of a sequel.” Brian Lowry of Variety said that The Legend of Zorro is “considerably less charming than The Mask of Zorro”, but added that the film “gets by mostly on dazzling stunt work and the pleasure of seeing its dashing and glamorous leads back in cape and gown.” Lisa Schwarzbaum of Entertainment Weekly awarded the film a “B-” score. Schwarzbaum said that “too many scenes emphasize gross butchery over the elegance of the blade”, but added that the film is “well-oiled” and praised the “fancy fight sequences”. Stephen Hunter of The Washington Post reacted negatively, calling The Legend of Zorro “a waste of talent, time, and money” and “stupid and boring”. Marc Savlov of the Austin Chronicle was also not impressed, remarking that “there are precious few things for a Zorro fan – or a film fan, for that matter – not to loathe about The Legend of Zorro.” The film did reasonably well at the box office, grossing $142,400,065 internationally, but did not match the success of its predecessor. The film was released on DVD and VHS on January 31, 2006. It was later released on Blu-ray on December 11, 2007.